Wrestling Headlines
No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
    • HEADLINES
  • NEWS
    • WWE News, WWE Rumors and Spoilers
    • AEW News and Rumors
    • IMPACT Wrestling News and Rumors
    • ROH News and Rumors
    • NJPW News
    • MLW News
    • NWA Wrestling News
  • RESULTS
    • WWE Raw Results
    • WWE Smackdown Results
    • WWE NXT Results
    • WWE 205 Live Results
    • WWE PPV Results
    • WWE House Show Results
    • AEW Results
    • IMPACT Wrestling Results
    • IMPACT PPV Results
    • Ring of Honor Results
    • NJPW Results
    • MLW Wrestling Results
    • NWA Results
    • Lucha Underground Results
    • Indy Wrestling Results
  • COLUMNS
    • Hustle
    • Sir Sam’s Court
    • The Brand Extension
    • Tim Rose Jr
    • Cool Points
    • The Main Event
    • El Gringo Loco
    • Imp’s Adventures
    • Doctor’s Orders
    • Column of the Month
    • LOP Hall Of Fame
  • PODCASTS
    • Imp’s LOP Radio Adventure
    • Kingdom of Honour
    • LOP Aftershock
    • All Night Long Wrestling Podcast
    • Quick and Painless Pro Wrestling Podcast
    • The Legacy Series
    • The Doc Says
  • FORUMS
  • CONTACT
Wrestling Headlines
No Result
View All Result

Home » COLUMNS » Between The Flips & Fists » Jim Ross’ High-Spot Commentary Right Place, Wrong Space

Jim Ross’ High-Spot Commentary Right Place, Wrong Space

by Andrew Ardizzi
December 15, 2020
in Between The Flips & Fists
A A
4
Jim Ross’ High-Spot Commentary Right Place, Wrong Space

Tony Schiavone and Jim Ross call the action at an AEW event. Ross has recently come under fire for critical comments he made about a common high spot used in WWE and AEW.

2.7k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Jim Ross is the greatest wrestling commentator to ever wear a headset, but recently he’s evolved into a problem for the promotions he’s worked for.

We give Michael Cole a lot of…”sass”…quite often for his commentary style. He may very well have his fans who will defend his work until the end of time; he’s not the worst, nor is he the best. Yet throughout the entire time he’s worked for WWE, he has yet to step out and openly criticize its business model, its practices or the WWE product itself. In fact, whether we like it or not, we’ve probably heard “it’s Boss time,” or “it’s the Big Dog!” a few million times too many. And that’s fine, because it’s what the “boss” wants and in these relative terms WWE is what it is, and that’s perfectly OK.

Ring of Honor’s Ian Riccaboni and NWA’s Joe Galli have a great deal in common with WWE’s up-and-coming play-by-play announcers like Vic Joseph and Tom Phillips. They’re skilled, young speakers who know what they’re tasked to do and commentate to the best of their ability while being wholly engaged in their work and the promotion’s product.

If you were a fan of WWF in the ’90s you might remember Kevin Kelly. He currently does commentary for NJPW’s English language broadcasts. Much like WWE’s announcers, Riccaboni, Galli or even Josh Matthews in Impact, they don’t consciously do or say anything to hurt or undermine the product/company they work for. They do what they’re paid to do, which is to discuss their company on-air in a manner that pushes the narratives forward regardless of whether it’s excellent, fantastic, great, good, poor or incomprehensibly absurd.

Mauro Ranallo, formerly of NXT, is one of the best all-around combat sports announcers. It doesn’t matter if he commentates on boxing, MMA or pro wrestling, he works hard to support the product and does so with enthusiasm. Conversely, Tony Schiavone (while he may not have Ranallo’s pedigree) has done an excellent job on Dynamite pushing the company product forward and does so with absolute enthusiasm. And if either ever had anything critical to say, you wouldn’t know it.

This brings us back to Ross, who for many of us was the voice of wrestling throughout the ’90s and perhaps even as far back into the ’80s if you were an NWA/WCW fan then. This isn’t to say that he isn’t a great announcer. Are his references or style somewhat dated? Sure, but so are most of my jokes and cursive writing. Is he any less knowledgeable, capable or worthwhile to have around the commentary desk or behind the scenes? No, not in the slightest.

A handful of stories have come out over the last week, one more so looking at the relationship between Vince McMahon and Pat Patterson, and another about Arn Anderson and Cody Rhodes. In both those stories Cody and Chris Jericho detail how Patterson and Anderson in their respective situations saw and see the value in openly discussing the highs or lows of a performance behind closed doors. If an angle sucked, Patterson told Vince just as readily if something was great. If Cody had a garbage match, Anderson told him; only praising his work where it was warranted.

That’s a running theme, a dynamic built off open-dialogue behind the scenes with the notion being that matches or the entire product on the larger scale can be improved by tweaking what isn’t working. Constructive feedback is how improvements are made; there’s an old line from HBO series “The Newsroom” that, paraphrased, says the first step in fixing any problem is acknowledging there’s a problem in the first place.

That problem, right now, is Jim Ross beyond any reverence we might have for him. He’s earned our respect over the years for being part of some of the biggest calls in wrestling in its biggest boom years. However over the last several years, even prior to AEW when he was commentating for NJPW, he openly chastised and railed against the product he’s supposed to be promoting on-air during broadcasts. That isn’t conducive to growing any audience if your lead commentator is undercutting the product or the talent (many of whom are young and learning). And if he isn’t doing that on the air, he’s used other media forms to convey the same thoughts.

I agree with Jim Ross’ recent comments, specifically about the high spot where a group of wrestlers stands together while another performs a plancha or dive onto them as they moronically stand still. It’s a common place spot, especially in WWE and AEW right now, but logistically it makes sense. However, Ross is completely in the wrong to have vocalized these thoughts in the way he has in the open. The criticisms are fair comment and agreeable, however, calling back to the stories about Pat Patterson and Arn Anderson, there’s a constructive and destructive approach to giving feedback and what Ross has done — for all his experience and knowledge — is wholly detrimental to the growth and development of AEW during this small window where the company has an opportunity to actually help improve wrestling as a whole; to additionally push WWE to up its game.

The reality of the situation is that if Ross made these comments publicly in WWE, he’d at the very least be reprimanded by McMahon. Worst case, if it continued as it has in AEW, he’d probably be let go. This isn’t to advocate for Ross’ removal from the Dynamite announce team, or from the company. This is, however, a test for Tony Khan to step up and right his ship away from a harmful element that’s been allowed to fester for a while now. It’s Jim Ross’ right to speak his mind as he has both positively and negatively, and his recent point is completely valid. However there’s a time and place for that criticism, and it isn’t in an article or a podcast.

For example, if any one of us went on Twitter and openly undercut the company we work for and disparaged its mission, we’d be fired regardless or at the very least reprimanded if its interests were compromised. I’ve witnessed the result first hand; social platforms are not the venue to discuss and undermine your employer ever, which is what Ross has done both on and off the air. There is definite value in what Ross said in the right setting, in a meeting, beyond closed doors or off to the side one-on-one after a show.

Jim Ross possesses a wealth of knowledge, but as it is he has been using his powers haphazardly as opposed to doing what he has in the past and helped along younger talent. It’s even worse when you hear stories about former wrestlers like Fit Finlay, Shane Helms or Jerry Lynn being such positive influences behind the scenes, or current talent like Dustin Rhodes and Thunder Rosa and their push to help the AEW womens’ division. It helps the whole.

Jim Ross can do better than he has, he can be better as an asset not just to AEW itself, but to each wrestler who heard him call WWE events during their formative years and may have called some of their landmark favourites. He matters. His commentary matters. No matter what company he works for, he has an immense wealth of care, passion and enthusiasm for wrestling.

I believe he wants AEW to be successful, he’s said far more positive things overall, but in order for that to happen he needs to understand his words and opinions carry serious weight. But realistically in order to get to that point, he needs to admit the avenue he’s chosen to communicate his feedback does far more damage than it does to cultivate the next crop of wrestlers who may be elite stars in WWE, AEW, ROH, NJPW, Impact or wherever else one, five or 10 years down the road.

RECENT POSTS

Further Details On WWE Monday Night Raw’s Wild Fireball Finish

IMPACT, WWE, and AEW Stars Comment On The Retirement Of Madison Rayne

AJ Styles Looks Back On His First Days Training To Be A Pro-Wrestler

Matt Cardona Reportedly Not Under Contract With IMPACT Wrestling

WWE “Top 10” Superstars Throwing Fire, Ric Flair Says Hulk Hogan Has Always Been There For Him

NJPW Road To The New Beginning Results 1/17/21

Previous Post

Steve Austin on How Good Pat McAfee Is In WWE, Hosting vs. Acting, “Straight Up Steve Austin”

Next Post

Anthony Henry Discusses The Legacy Of EVOLVE’s Talented Roster, How He Feels Satisfied With His Career If A Contract Doesn’t Come and more

COLUMNS

Can’t Knock The Hustle: Can Paul Heyman Bring Out The Best (Or Worst) In Apollo Crews?

Can’t Knock The Hustle: Can Paul Heyman Bring Out The Best (Or Worst) In Apollo Crews?

January 13, 2021
Kota Ibushi, ‘Switchblade’ Jay White Story is Timeless

Kota Ibushi, ‘Switchblade’ Jay White Story is Timeless

January 12, 2021
Wrestling Headlines 2020 End of Year Awards Results

Wrestling Headlines 2020 End of Year Awards Results

January 11, 2021
Can’t Knock The Hustle: Wrestling’s 30 Under 30 List (WWE, AEW, NXT, New Japan, and more)

Can’t Knock The Hustle: Wrestling’s 30 Under 30 List (WWE, AEW, NXT, New Japan, and more)

January 6, 2021
Mitchell, Disco Inferno Commentaries on Brodie Lee Were Completely Tone Deaf

Mitchell, Disco Inferno Commentaries on Brodie Lee Were Completely Tone Deaf

January 4, 2021
Doctor’s Orders: The Top 10 Wrestlers of 2020

Doctor’s Orders: The Top 10 Wrestlers of 2020

January 3, 2021

PODCASTS

An 8 Year Old Takes Over The Doc Says Podcast (Royal Rumble Preview)

An 8 Year Old Takes Over The Doc Says Podcast (Royal Rumble Preview)

January 17, 2021
WWE NXT

WH Radio WWE NXT Review, Jan. 14th, 2021 – IMPACT Stars Makes NXT Debut!

January 14, 2021
RAW

WH Radio WWE RAW Review, Jan. 12th, 2021 – Alexa Bliss Fireballs Randy Orton?!

January 12, 2021
WWF: The Legacy Series – Warrior vs. Creative (07-90)

WWF: The Legacy Series – Warrior vs. Creative (07-90)

January 10, 2021
Kingdom of Honor–AEW, G1 Climax 30, and the Pure Title

Kingdom of Honor–Reviewing an amazing week of pro wrestling

January 10, 2021
ANLWP: 5 Best Royal Rumble Matches

ANLWP: 5 Best Royal Rumble Matches

January 9, 2021

HOME

Wrestling Headlines

ABOUT US

WrestlingHeadlines.com is your daily source for pro wrestling news headlines. Our coverage includes WWE, AEW, IMPACT, NJPW, ROH, MLW and more. Formerly Lords of Pain (LOP), we have been publishing WWE news and rumors since 1998! We are an independent news outlet and are not affiliated with any wrestling promotion.

STAY CONNECTED

  • 144.7k Fans
  • 11.2k Followers
  • 3.2k Subscribers

Home | News | Results | Columns | Radio | Contact | Privacy Policy

No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
    • HEADLINES
  • NEWS
    • WWE News, WWE Rumors and Spoilers
    • AEW News and Rumors
    • IMPACT Wrestling News and Rumors
    • ROH News and Rumors
    • NJPW News
    • MLW News
    • NWA Wrestling News
  • RESULTS
    • WWE Raw Results
    • WWE Smackdown Results
    • WWE NXT Results
    • WWE 205 Live Results
    • WWE PPV Results
    • WWE House Show Results
    • AEW Results
    • IMPACT Wrestling Results
    • IMPACT PPV Results
    • Ring of Honor Results
    • NJPW Results
    • MLW Wrestling Results
    • NWA Results
    • Lucha Underground Results
    • Indy Wrestling Results
  • COLUMNS
    • Hustle
    • Sir Sam’s Court
    • The Brand Extension
    • Tim Rose Jr
    • Cool Points
    • The Main Event
    • El Gringo Loco
    • Imp’s Adventures
    • Doctor’s Orders
    • Column of the Month
    • LOP Hall Of Fame
  • PODCASTS
    • Imp’s LOP Radio Adventure
    • Kingdom of Honour
    • LOP Aftershock
    • All Night Long Wrestling Podcast
    • Quick and Painless Pro Wrestling Podcast
    • The Legacy Series
    • The Doc Says
  • FORUMS
  • CONTACT

Home | News | Results | Columns | Radio | Contact | Privacy Policy