WWE Hall of Famer Rob Van Dam has offered some pointed criticism of AEW’s creative approach, questioning the amount of freedom wrestlers have and taking issue with some of the more extreme elements featured on the company’s programming.
During an appearance on Wrestling with Rip Rogers, RVD addressed accusations of hypocrisy stemming from his criticism of AEW, particularly regarding Jon Moxley’s use of weapons and other controversial creative decisions.
Van Dam recalled being written off TNA television in 2010 after exceeding the number of appearances outlined in his contract. The storyline saw Abyss attack him with Janice, a wooden plank covered in nails, which RVD acknowledged was a questionable creative decision.
He compared that situation to Moxley’s use of a similar weapon in AEW, suggesting the promotion’s wrestlers have considerably more influence over their creative direction.
“Are you telling me that you think that Moxley was given this idea from a writer and they just went along with it? Maybe he thought it was stupid. I don’t buy that because I think the inmates are running the asylum. I think that’s what AEW is about, is the wrestlers get to do more of what they want,” Van Dam said.
“And that’s why there’s more variety, and that’s why, overall, in the big picture of things, it’s going to be a different style that to me is more amateurish, just like backyard matches than WWE, who seems to be going back to telling the stories with the wrestling, keeping it simple and making it make sense. It was getting so out of hand for a while that with AEW they burnt someone’s house down and I’ve never liked that when someone put staples in their face and stuff.”
The former WWE and ECW Champion also expressed frustration with modern wrestling matches that feature elaborate sequences requiring lengthy setups, arguing that such moments can undermine the presentation of legitimate competition.
“If the move that you want to do out in the ring, if the setup for it takes so long that it kills the whole match and kills the feeling of competition, then don’t do it because it exposes the business. And now it’s so obvious watching the guys, the young guys. And, you know, especially in the smaller company of the two, I’m getting heat for bashing AEW, and I’ll talk about that in a second, which I don’t do.”
Van Dam continued by reiterating his belief that AEW performers enjoy a level of creative control that contributes to the differences between the promotion and WWE.
“But that is a place where it seems more like the inmates are running the prison, you know? And it’s always been that way. I think that’s the idea with them: the boys have more control and power.”
Despite his criticism, Van Dam has previously worked with AEW. He made his promotional debut in August 2023, challenging Jack Perry for the FTW Championship, and subsequently made several appearances, including matches alongside Swerve Strickland, Hangman Page and HOOK.
